37 Palmer Terrace Sag Harbor Village, New York



37 Palmer Terrace Sag Harbor Village, New York


High on the top of the hill of one of the most beautiful and quiet streets in the middle of historic Sag Harbor Village, sits this exquisite home. The proud, nearly 5,000 sqft house, originally built in 1891,was totally restructured with new T beams and completely renovated by the current owner. No detail was left undone to bring the structure into the 21st-century, whilst keeping the historic detail and charm intact. The light-filled first floor features high ceilings, an open floor plan offering formal dining, chefs kitchen, living room, library and a den, which could always be separated by the original sliding doors. The second floor offers a grand master bedroom with separate sitting room and three additional bedrooms plus baths. The finished third floor is currently used as a sitting room, additional storage rooms and a bath room. The full basement is unfinished but offers great storage. The half-acre, beautifully landscaped property includes a 1.5 story guest cottage with full kitchen, a light filled art studio and heated Gunite pool. The fairy tale gardens include specimen trees, amazing flowers, water falls, wooden bridges and great terraces to entertain. Over time the house has undergone many changes, but it always kept the integrity, beauty and charm. Ready for the next owner who likes to enjoy a compound, a piece of history, private gardens and being just a stroll away from famous restaurants, shops and yacht harbor.


This listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman

Property Details:

  • 37 Palmer Terrace Sag Harbor Village, New York
  • Price: $4,450,000
  • Neighborhood: Sag Harbor Village
  • House
  • 5 Beds | 4 Baths | 2 Half Baths
  • Approximate Sq. Feet: 4,715
  • Lot Size: 0.52 Acres
  • Listing ID: H48419

Area Details:

Your Agent(s)
For Appointment Contact:
Michaela Keszler

Michaela Keszler

O: 631.204.2743

M: 631.525.3810

F: 631.204.6912

Email me »